Evidence Excluded from Mortgage Fraud Scheme Case - KWES NewsWest 9 / Midland, Odessa, Big Spring, TX: newswest9.com |

Evidence Excluded from Mortgage Fraud Scheme Case

 by Kim Powell

NewsWest 9

MIDLAND - Roughly 100 pages of written arguments were sent between the US District Court and the four defendants who are accused of a massive mortgage fraud scheme that involved about 800 properties and $45 million in bank loans. 

Investigators say that between March 2003 and August 2011 that the four came up with a "same-day property" flip scheme, where Stephen Hilliard and Michael Cowan would buy property used for one of their investment companies, and then sell the same property at a higher price to another investment company.

The two would receive mortgage loans by submitting fake and misleading documents to the bank. As for Cynthia Hirsch and Berta McFaddin, they are accused of getting the papers needed to get the properties and bank loans. 

Now, the court has been trying to get several categories of evidence excluded from the case as they could mislead the jury. 

According to court documents, the defendants have argued that, "evidence that they have repaid many of the fraudulently obtained loans and thus, as a consequence, the banks have been or are being made whole and will not suffer any loss." 

The court fears that could lead to the jury believing that there is no harm, no foul. Even though the four paid back the banks who fell victim to this scheme, a crime was still committed. 

Cowan argues that, "the very fact that the banks repaid and that the defendants had demonstrated a history of repayment, might provide a background context that would make any later misstatement (assuming one occurred) immaterial." 

Evidence that suggests the banks are partially responsible for not catching the fraud as it happened will also be prohibited from the case, as blaming the victim is not a defense in a mortgage fraud case. 

However, the court will allow evidence that the appraisals for the homes were legitimate.

Trial is set to start on September 2nd. 

  • NewsMore>>

  • TRAFFIC ALERT: City of Midland announces traffic signal repair for May 24

    TRAFFIC ALERT: City of Midland announces traffic signal repair for May 24

    (Source: Raycom Media)(Source: Raycom Media)

    The City of Midland has announced that there will be a traffic signal change at the intersection of Loop 250 and Midland Drive on Thursday.

    The City of Midland has announced that there will be a traffic signal change at the intersection of Loop 250 and Midland Drive on Thursday.

  • Summer Mummers returns for 70th season

    Summer Mummers returns for 70th season

    (Source: Midland Community Theatre)(Source: Midland Community Theatre)

    Summer Mummers is back at the Yucca Theater for its 70th season with “Diabolic Deeds on the Diamond or Wait-was that a squirrel in the infield?” 

    Summer Mummers is back at the Yucca Theater for its 70th season with “Diabolic Deeds on the Diamond or Wait-was that a squirrel in the infield?” 

  • Suspect arrested in hit -and-run investigation

    Suspect arrested in hit -and-run investigation

    (Source: Raycom Media)(Source: Raycom Media)

    Justin Lee Rodriguez, 22, has been charged with two counts of Fail to Stop and Render Aid “3rd Degree Felony”. An ongoing investigation and a Crime Stopper’s tip resulted in the suspect being identified. Rodriguez also reportedly had injuries consistent with being involved in a crash.

    Justin Lee Rodriguez, 22, has been charged with two counts of Fail to Stop and Render Aid “3rd Degree Felony”. An ongoing investigation and a Crime Stopper’s tip resulted in the suspect being identified. Rodriguez also reportedly had injuries consistent with being involved in a crash.

Powered by Frankly